banner
From the Editor
I’m pleased to be back home after a road trip of 4120 km. There’s a lot to see and do in our great land. I visited the Rotary Club of Longreach and there’s report on that in this newsletter. Thanks to Juris for his report on Professor Asmi Wood’s talk on the Voice referendum at our Zoom meeting last week. There’s information on our next two meetings, including this week’s roster; three upcoming events; and, as usual, some humour to end the newsletter.
Correction
Last week I accidently wrote “Melrose Primary School” instead of “Majura Primary School”. It is the latter that we are sponsoring book prizes for. I take this error as evidence that my travel was relaxing!
Stephen McMillan
 
Last week’s meeting: ANU Professor Asmi Wood speaking on the Voice
We’re so used to hearing politicised, overblown and sometimes clearly false opinions, on the forthcoming Referendum on the Voice to Parliament and Executive Government of the Commonwealth, that it’s possible we can’t tell fear-mongering and outright lies from an honest statement of the simple facts.  
 
How good would it be for people all around Australia to hear the unvarnished and unembellished facts on the legal and Constitutional issues to do with the forthcoming referendum on The Voice, from Constitutional lawyer, Professor Asmi Wood, ANU College of Law, expert in Constitutional recognition of Indigenous people in Australia?
 
Professor Wood says, yes, there is about a 20 per cent minority of Indigenous voices saying that the Voice doesn’t go far enough.  Sure.  But it’s a start.  Treaty and Truth-telling can come later.  From his perspective as an expert on Constitutional law, contrary to a further strand of negative argument, there is nothing scary about the proposed Voice as it stands.  The Voice will not adversely affect the people.  The Voice will not racialise the Constitution.  (Should I say it?  It already is explicitly racist.)  There will be no flood of cases to the High Court.
 
Professor Wood gave us a potted history of the efforts, successes and remaining hurdles to do with the history of native title and the seeking of an Aboriginal and Torres Straits Islander Voice to Parliament.  He pointed out that the 1992 Mabo High Court decision on property rights to Native Title arose from English law as a burden on the King as applied to land.  Freehold is a stronger right.  Native Title is a much weaker right.  Subsequently the majority of our Parliament voted almost unanimously for recognition in the Constitution done in Parliament.
 
We have, in effect, a Constitutional system which is hybrid: the “Washminster” system, a combination of the Washington and Westminster systems.  Our Parliament is bound by the Constitution.  Under it, we need a double majority to pass a referendum – more than 50 per cent of the people and more than 50 per cent of our States, unlike England, which does not have the notion of a referendum.  The proposal is a modest measure, as indicated by the Prime Minister.
 
We now have a Bill for an Act in Parliament to alter the Constitution.  The proposed Chapter IX, Clause 129, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice, sets out three brief and straight-forward matters “In recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the First Peoples of Australia”.  The first names the body; the second allows it to make representations to Parliament and the Executive Government; and the third allows Parliament to make laws with respect to that body (The Voice).
 
The key part of that second part, provision 129(ii), is “may make representations”.  This gives Indigenous people a voice without taking away anything from the majority or from the power of the Parliament to operate efficiently or effectively.  Most people, lawyers in particular, believe it would improve processes.
 
Professor Wood, whose second main strand of current research centres around Indigenous Participation in Higher Education, points out that most funding for Indigenous people in Australia has gone to the cities, little of which reaches the people for schools, hospitals and the like.  He finds that education is of the greatest benefit to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Establishment of the Voice is the most likely way that the current deficiencies for Australia’s Indigenous people might be remedied.
 
The referendum, if successful, entrenches a Voice. This is the key difference between the parties, i.e., the Coalition opposes entrenchment.
 
Either way (entrenched or otherwise) the functions of a Voice according to either side’s model will be legislated and therefore the function is determined by the government of the day.
 
Gaining the government’s ear would be easier and less subject to the whims of governments as they change through elections if the Voice were entrenched.  One might expect a more continuous, productive and less frustrating arrangement of consultation from this than currently exists.
 
May more people hear what Professor Asmi Wood has to say on the subject!
Juris Jakovics
 
Visit to Rotary Club of Longreach
Longreach Rotary meeting. The tablet on table allows for  Zoom participants.
Firewood advertising board adjacent main highway.
Rotary Park in Longreach.
On Wednesday, 9 August, I attended the Rotary Club of Longreach's weekly dinner meeting.  Nine members were in attendance that evening (two via Zoom, the rest in person). It was an unusual meeting: the Club was being consulted on the development of a “Regional Drought Resilience Plan” and members spoke of their experience of the recent drought in the area. The Club would visit a small, remote community and put on a movie (using a portable projector and screen) and BBQ. During the social interaction people would open up about their needs, and the Club could offer some assistance or advice.
 
The Club earns significant income from selling firewood through a Shell service station. This is mostly bought by tourists, bringing money into the region. The wood is donated by landowners (often tough old gidgee fence posts) and sawed and bagged by members (who stay on for coffee after the work is done).
Stephen McMillan
 
Next meeting
On Thursday, 17 August, we will meet at Commonwealth Club and hear from Bruno Ferronato (pictured above) on “Long necked tortoises – are foxes getting the better of them?”. If you have not already responded to the invitation sent out by Ross, please do so before 11 am tomorrow (Tuesday, 15 August).
 
Duty Roster
Date
17 August
24 August
31 August
7 September
Door
Ross Brown
Informal meeting
Ross Brown
Ross Brown
Open meeting; introduce President; and Toast to Rotary
Stephen McMillan
Informal meeting
Eric Carmody
Sally Goodspeed
Thank speaker and write up for Bulletin
Astrida Upitis
Informal meeting
John Little
Liz Scrivener
If you are not able to perform your allocated duty, please arrange a replacement and advise Acting President Bill. Please advise Stephen of any planned absences to avoid being rostered on while away.
 
Rotary Youth Program of Enrichment (RYPEN)
RYPEN is a challenging weekend for year 9 students who show a positive and caring attitude in everyday life. It RYPEN is not a leadership camp; the program is aimed at students with good potential who could benefit from a boost in their self-esteem and confidence. The principal aim is to communicate a series of ideas, discuss social issues and run a series of challenging team-building activities that will assist the participants in developing communication and life skills. If you know someone who could be interested in participating, please contact Stephen to discuss.
Stephen McMillan
 
A Father’s Day Present: Kotaro Nagano in Recital performing Fryderyk Chopin
 With Father’s Day just around the corner, why not tell your family you would like a present which the whole family can enjoy together. An engaging celebration of some of the most intimate, exquisite and beautiful piano music in the world by the incomparable Fryderyk Chopin – Mazurka, Etudes, a Prelude, Waltzes, an Impromptu, Scherzo, Nocturne, Berceuse and Sonata. It will be a Sunday to celebrate and remember!
 
It will be performed by the acclaimed Japanese pianist Kotaro Nagano the First Prize Winner and the People’s Choice prize winner of the 2nd Australian International Chopin Piano Competition 2014. Canberra’s audiences love Kotaro just as much as he loves Canberra. He returns after a three-year absence due to COVID.
 
Join us on Sunday 27 August 2023, at Wesley Music Centre, 3.00-5.00 pm.
Online bookings are essential as seating is limited: https://friendsofchopinaustralia.simpletix.com/. 
All queries to Ben James, President 00466 620825.
 
This event is presented by the Friends of Chopin Australia which gratefully thanks its sponsors the Polish Embassy in Canberra, the Council of Polish Organisations in the ACT including Wild Fox Wines, and Raw Vine Estate. It is part of the Friends inaugural Australian Chopin Festival 27 August, 28 September – 2 October 2023 https://www.friendsofchopin.org.au/events
Olek Gancarz on behalf of The Friends of Chopin Australia
 
 
Nusa Tengarra Association (NTA) Donor Trip 22-28 October 2023 
The NTA is running a trip to its aid project locations on the island of Flores, specifically to introduce donors to the communities it supports and to show how donor funds are being used. This is a fabulous opportunity to visit communities and institutions in this area, to be introduced to their customs, issues, and how the NTA is working together with them to improve their lives. If interested, please contact the NTA Executive Officer, Phil Domaschenz, by email phil2dom@gmail.com or phone 0406 930 835.
 
Be clear about what you want
Cartoon courtesy of Facebook
Please add mailservice@clubrunner.ca to your safe sender list or address book.
To view our privacy policy, click here.
 
ClubRunner
102-2060 Winston Park Drive, Oakville, ON, L6H 5R7
Advertisement for ClubRunner Mobile
News Notes is sent out each Monday.
Please send items for inclusion to sjmcmillan1974@live.com by 10 am Monday.